President Trump's planned 250-foot memorial arch ran into its second federal judge in a single week on Friday. U.S. District Judge Leonie Brinkema, sitting in Alexandria, Virginia, said from the bench that she will issue a preliminary injunction keeping the project on hold while a lawsuit brought by the Arlington County Board works its way through her court.
The ruling follows an order from Judge Tanya Chutkan in Washington, who barred construction in early November and extended that order on Wednesday. The arch would stand roughly twice the height of the Lincoln Memorial, according to the Associated Press.
One caution up front: the reports so far describe Brinkema as saying she "will issue" or plans to issue the injunction. Whether a signed written order has actually been entered has not been confirmed.
A Clinton Appointee Weighs a 1925 Law
Brinkema is an appointee of President Bill Clinton. NPR reported that she said she saw no "way" the government could win on the merits. According to CNN, she called the effort "such a rushed job."
At the center of the dispute is authority. NPR reported that the project lacks congressional approval, which the administration has not sought. The government argues instead that a 1925 law covering two shorter columns that were never built also covers the arch. Brinkema rejected that reading. The AP reported that she noted the statute made no provision for an arch and predated the airport.
Chutkan, an Obama appointee, also ruled against the project. Axios reported that her order said: "Congress has not enacted any statute authorizing construction of the Arch." According to the AP, her first order came hours after a federal planning commission approved the arch.
The County's Case and the White House Answer
Arlington County sued in October. It is represented by Democracy Forward, which confirmed Friday's ruling. Senior counsel Kate Talmor called the arch a "massive vanity project," according to NPR and USA Today.
The county's complaints go beyond paperwork. Arlington says the nearby cemetery holds roughly 24 to 27 funerals each weekday, according to NPR reporting carried by KMUW. CTV reported that the site would sit about 3,000 feet from Reagan National Airport and that some aviation experts have raised safety concerns. Those points come from the county's claims or single outlets and should be read as allegations, not findings. NPR also reported that Kennedy family members have joined the fight against the project. Axios noted the National Park Service backed the arch even while acknowledging it "would alter several historic views."
The White House is standing firm. Spokesman Davis Ingle told CNN: "The judiciary should not be abused to politicize a structure designed to unite our nation."
The Justice Department Plans to Fight
The Justice Department filed a 44-page response in the case on Nov. 13 and, according to USA Today, said it plans to "immediately" appeal.
What Comes Next
Three things are ahead. Brinkema is to issue a written preliminary injunction. The Justice Department says it will appeal immediately. And Chutkan is weighing a longer injunction. CNN reports her current order runs to Dec. 3, while Axios, CTV and Fox5 describe it as lasting two weeks, so the exact deadline is unsettled. Axios called the next two months pivotal for the project.


Winter Brings More Than Snow and Ice: Get Ready for Power Outages and Closed Roads
Try Ready Hour Emergency Food for $34.99 With This 72-Hour Sample Pack
Bake Pizza Anywhere: The Ember Portable Oven by InstaFire
3 Months of Food for One Person: 846 Servings, Up to a 25-Year Shelf Life
Emergency Food That Stores Up to 25 Years: Ready Hour Kits From 3 Days to 6 Months
Ready Hour 4-Week Food Supply: 2,000+ Calories a Day, Stores Up to 25 Years
0 Comments
Be the first to comment.