The U.S. Department of Education and the California Department of Education read a federal student privacy law differently, and the difference decides when a parent must sign off before a child answers a school survey on sensitive subjects.
A New York Post story dated Oct. 23 carries a URL slug suggesting California school districts are being probed over a student survey with intimate details. Patriot Daily Wire has not been able to read the Post's report. Its details, including which districts are involved, what survey was used, how many students took it, and who announced a probe and when, are unconfirmed here. We also have not confirmed that the story concerns the federal letter discussed below.
What can be described is the legal disagreement over the Protection of Pupil Rights Amendment, known as PPRA.
What the federal law says
According to the California Department of Education, the PPRA requires prior written parental consent before a school can "require" a student to submit to a survey that reveals information in protected areas. The state refers to eight such areas in total. The portion of its guidance available to us listed political affiliations or beliefs, mental or psychological problems, sex behavior or attitudes, illegal or demeaning behavior, critical appraisals of close family members, and privileged relationships. The remaining areas were not visible to us.
The state says the U.S. Department of Education's Student Privacy Policy Office sent a letter dated Aug. 26, 2026. As the state describes it, the office takes the view that every survey touching those areas "requires" submission, so active consent is always needed, even if participation is voluntary.
California's reading
The California Department of Education posted a letter to district superintendents titled "Surveys under the PPRA and Records under FERPA." We saw only a search snippet of the page, not the full text. The web address suggests a date of about Sept. 23, though that is not confirmed.
According to that snippet, the department said it had received inquiries about the August federal letter. It says the law applies only when a survey "requires" participation. It also says California law is unchanged and in some ways stricter than the federal rule.
Whether the surveys at issue were mandatory is therefore disputed. The federal office says consent is always needed. The state says it is needed only when participation is required.
Background on other federal disputes with California
The survey question follows other disputes between the federal government and the state. EdWeek reported in February that on Jan. 28, Education Secretary Linda McMahon and another official wrote to the California education department finding that the state violates the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act, or FERPA. The finding concerned AB 1955, a 2024 law that bars requiring staff to disclose a student's gender identity to others without the student's consent. California sued, saying FERPA imposes no duty to disclose absent a parental request.
EdSource, in an undated report, said four California districts are under a federal compliance review over gender identity policies: San Francisco Unified, Graves Elementary, Santa Rita Union and Soledad Unified, the last three in Monterey County. We have not confirmed whether any of them are connected to the survey matter.
What happens next
Next steps are unknown. Still to be established are which districts, if any, are under review, what survey is at issue, and how the Education Department and the affected districts respond. We have not yet checked for responses from the districts or the California Department of Education.
Retirees On SS Are Due A Large Surprise This Week
Lulutox: A 12-Ingredient Tea Blend With Matcha, Goji Berries and Yerba Mate
Put Tin Foil in the Dishwasher? Here's Why Seniors Do It
Fièra: A 3-Step Skincare Routine Formulated for Mature Skin
Social Security Changes Coming in 2026 That Impact Everyone
Who Has The Cheapest Home Insurance? (Check Your ZIP Code)
0 Comments
Be the first to comment.