Mamdani's Second-Home Tax Bills Reportedly Go to About 8,000 Properties

Jimmy Brown Politics 3 min read 0 Comments

New York City's Department of Finance is reportedly poised to send pied-à-terre surcharge bills to about 8,000 properties, roughly half the 17,000 owners it notified in August, according to Bloomberg Tax. Whether the bills have actually been mailed was not confirmed. The New York Post is reported to have cited a similar figure, though that account was not independently reviewed.

The number also falls well short of the state's estimate that about 13,000 homes would be covered. The city has not lowered its revenue forecast. A Nov. 12 city budget update kept the projection at $500 million a year, a figure the city comptroller's office is reported to dispute.

The gap matters because Mayor Zohran Mamdani's tax is supposed to raise half a billion dollars a year, and the list of properties facing a bill is much shorter than the list of owners first notified.

How the List Got Shorter

The drop came after owners filed exemption requests ahead of an Oct. 13 deadline. Bloomberg Tax reported that at least 8,900 exemptions were granted and that about 8,100 properties will get bills. According to the Post's account, as relayed by Gateway Pundit, the city received more than 10,000 exemption requests in all. The notes available do not say on what basis the exemptions were granted.

The precise count should be treated as approximate. The Post figure of about 8,000 is attributed to officials, Bloomberg's is about 8,100, and the city has not published a tally. The reports describe the bills as poised to go out. Payment deadlines are reportedly set for January, and appeals to the city's Tax Commission are possible through March 2027.

The mayor is not backing off. Speaking to reporters on Nov. 10, Mamdani said, per Bloomberg Tax, "We continue to be confident in its ability to raise half a billion dollars per year."

The comptroller's office has projected less. An earlier Yahoo report put that office's projection at $340 million to $380 million, with collections possibly falling over time. That range appeared in only one report available to us, and the $500 million figure is the city's own estimate.

A Rocky Rollout and a Trip to Court

Mamdani announced the tax in April outside Ken Griffin's penthouse, according to a Yahoo report relaying the Post. State lawmakers passed it in late May, and in July the Department of Finance posted a roll of about 900,000 properties. The August notices followed, and so did a lawsuit, filed Aug. 7.

Mastro told CBS New York: "They had the state data on who paid 2025 taxes or applied for extensions by August 12, days later." Mamdani's answer, also to CBS New York, was that "at the time that we sent those out, we did not have access to the 2025 income tax filings." He also played down the scope, telling CNN it amounted to "17,000 homeowners out of a city of eight and a half million."

The response deadline was extended to Sept. 18. On Sept. 29, Justice Wayne Ozzi of Staten Island Supreme Court issued a ruling ordering the rollout scrapped. A unanimous panel of the Appellate Division, Second Department, later reversed that ruling and dismissed the suit, according to Yahoo. The exact date was not confirmed, though reports place it in early November. The panel did not decide whether the Department of Finance broke its own rule by skipping 2024 income-tax data.

The Numbers Still in Dispute

The figures do not line up yet. The state estimated 13,000 covered homes, the city is reportedly billing about 8,000 properties, and the comptroller's office is reported to expect less than the $500 million the city projects.

We have not read the Post or Yahoo stories in full, the Department of Finance bill notice, or the Nov. 12 budget update. Their figures here come from search snippets and secondary relays and could change when the city publishes its own count.

What Comes Next

Bills are described as poised to go out, with payments reportedly due in January and appeals running through March 2027. The first hard numbers on actual collections, rather than projections, will show how the city's $500 million estimate compares with the comptroller's range.

Share X f ✉

You May Like

Sponsored

0 Comments

Be the first to comment.

Leave a comment

No account needed. Comments are reviewed before they appear. Keep it civil; no links.